seasonal made-to-order menu
Sweet Pies | Savories | Pastries | packaged goods
All orders must be picked up during the day, during open shop hours.
Pre-ordered pies and pastries can be ordered online below, in person, or over the phone. Feel free to call 614-268-3662 to place an order or ask any questions!
**If pies or pastries are not picked up on the specified day during open hours, and we have not been notified of an issue or delay, the items will be donated to a local food pantry. No refunds.
Sweet Pies
Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie
$40.00
Ginger Cranberry Pear Pie
$45.00
Tip the Baker
$5.00
Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie
$40.00
Honey Apple Pie
$40.00
Buckeye Cream Pie
$40.00